Presented below is Srila Bhakti Siddhanta Saraswati Thakura’s article titled “Organised Religion (Putana and Kamsa).”
I say it is required reading in the hope of drawing the attention of our readers to two important points explained in the essay that follows which, I pray, will facilitate the proper understanding of their meaning.
The first, found in the story of the killing of Putana, should slay for good a long-standing, unfounded criticism of our Gurdeva, Srila Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, by a Gaudiya devotee of some renown whose pen he mistook for a sword to be used to attack our jagat guru’s description of Krishna’s appearance.
Fortunately, the firefly’s criticism was scarcely seen or noticed in the light of Srila Prabhupada’s brilliant sun, whose only fault, so to speak, was to inundate the entire world with the tidal wave of mercy he generated from the ocean of mercy known as Srila Bhakti Siddhanta Saraswati Thakura.
What the reader will find, in the article originally published in The Harmonist, is that Srila Prabhupada, Swami Maharaja, exactly reproduced the account of Krishna’s appearance in every important dimension as it was related by his spiritual master, Srila Bhakti Siddhanta Saraswati Thakura.
The second point to be grasped is found in Srila Saraswati Thakura’s analysis of organized religion, which reveals the dangers and, particular to our interests, the methodologies of the transformation of such organizations from spiritual to material.
These transformations have wrought great trouble, chaos and confusion upon the spiritual aspirants caught in the midst of such transformations while their eyes have barely had the chance to open during the short time from their spiritual birth to the time they, like young birds, are faced with the challenge of independent flight, while still so immature as to be almost incapable of comprehending their surroundings and its accompanying dangers.
The greatest dangers to these fledglings come in the aftermath of the disappearance of their spiritual preceptor from those charged with their protection, but who can behave with great cruelty towards the young who fail to escape the nest before being set upon by their cruel, or even well intended but short sighted, institutional leaders, whose real interest is only in their own perceived self preservation.
“Putana is the slayer of all infants. The baby, when he or she comes out of the mother’s womb, falls at once into the clutches of the pseudo-teachers of religion. These teachers are successful in forestalling the attempts of the good preceptor whose help is never sought by the atheists of this world at the baptisms of their children. This is ensured by the arrangements of all the established churches of the world.”
Salvation, according to the belief of the cruel or short sighted institutional leaders, is not to be found in the spiritual instruction of the transcendental founder of the organization, but with the organization itself. The organization was originally constructed to perform like a machine, which functions perfectly as long as it is directed by a transcendent personality whose only object is to use it to increase the productivity and efficiency of the delivery system for transporting spiritual consciousness into the mundane world from the plane of Vaikuntha.
“It is not from any deliberate opposition to the ordained clergy that these observations are made. The original purpose of the established churches of the world may not be always objectionable. But no stable religious arrangement for instructing the masses has yet been successful. The supreme Lord Sri Krishna Chaitanya, in pursuance of the teaching of the scriptures, enjoins all absence of conventionalism for the teachers of the eternal religion. It does not follow that the mechanical adoption of the unconventional life by any person will make him a fit teacher of religion.”
Bereft of its transcendental operator, the institutional operators take over the controls; generally after hard fought battles for them. Their myopia, inexperience, ineptness or indifference relative to the spiritual foundation of the institution causes the machine to become unstable and wander, until it is no longer able to maintain a connection with the pipeline that was originally supplying the spiritual consciousness it was intended to transport and distribute. If any attempts are made to compensate for the disconnect, they look to the organizational by-laws and doctrines that may actually succeed in producing larger and larger quantities of product but, without any means of analyzing its quality, it rapidly deteriorates; even to the point that it is no longer recognizable.
“Regulation is necessary for controlling the inherent worldliness of conditioned souls. But no mechanical regulation has any value even for such a purpose. The bonafide teacher of the religion is neither any product nor the favourer of any mechanical system. In his hands no system has likewise the chance of degenerating if not a lifeless arrangement. The mere pursuit of fixed doctrines and fixed liturgies cannot hold a person to the true spirit of doctrine or liturgy.”
To compensate for this disconnect from the spiritual pipeline, an energetic crusade is employed by the spiritually disconnected organization, much in the fashion of Orwell’s famous turnabout from “Four legs good, two legs bad.” to “Two legs good, four legs bad.” The purpose of this crusade is to establish the organization as a bonafide substitute for its spiritual founder. The turnabout may be represented crudely, for our purposes, as, “Guru primary, organization secondary.” to “Organization primary, guru secondary.”
This will be accompanied by a great propaganda campaign declaring monopoly rights to a huge stockpile of spiritual goods that can only be acquired from the organization holding the monopoly. In actuality the propaganda is merely a substitution for the spiritual goods themselves. To borrow an analogy from Srila Sridhara Maharaja, while the billboards declare the organization to be holding great riches, an audit will show it to be bankrupt. Anyone brave enough, or foolish enough, to point out these discrepancies is labeled a heretic, traitor, devil or something similarly disparaging, so as to discredit his view, even though the facts support it.
“The idea of an organized church in an intelligible form, indeed, marks the close of the living spiritual movement. The great ecclesiastical establishments are the dykes and the dams to retain the current that cannot be held by any such contrivances. They, indeed, indicate a desire on the part of the masses to exploit a spiritual movement for their own purpose. They also unmistakably indicate the end of the absolute and unconventional guidance of the bonafide spiritual teacher.”
This last point above should be very carefully considered as it is the cause of great sorrow, disappointment and displeasure for the pure devotees, the spiritual preceptors and all those who act as the spiritual guardians in the line of Sri Rupa.
I urge the reader, who I expect to consist principally of devotees of Sriman Mahaprabhu and His lineage, to look past Srila Saraswati Thakura’s use of terms like literal interpretationists, atheists, lexicographical interpreters, empiricists and so forth, to see how the concepts he presents apply equally to the leaders and supporters of any institution or organization that becomes dislodged from the spiritual fountainhead of its founder; no matter how closely its facade resembles that of one dedicated to the preaching and practicing of Krishna Consciousness.
Humbly submitted for the satisfaction of my Divine Master,
Swami B.K. Giri
Organised Religion (Putana and Kamsa)
By Srila Bhakti Siddhanta Saraswati Thakura
From the essay “Putana” printed in the January, February and March 1932 edition of The Harmonist, (Sri Sajjana-Tosani). Each of the demons written about represents different anarthas to be overcome in the pursuit of suddha-bhakti. They are delineated in Srila Bhakti Vinoda Thakura’s Sri Caitanya-Siksamrita, published in 1886. These metaphors are presented before each of the three articles by Srila Bhakti Siddhanta Sarasvati Thakura, as well as a closing paragraph from the same work by Srila Bhakti Vinoda Thakura for further clarification.
Killing of Putana
“The conduct of Sri Krsna is two fold i.e., eternal and occasional. In Goloka, eternal conduct and astakaliya-lila exists at all times. In Bhauma Vandavana that astakaliya-lila is mixed up with occasional lila. Going from Vraja and coming back and killing asuras are occasional lila. Such work is inevitable on the part of the aspirant while he lives in this material world. Occasional lila is in existence at Goloka in a negative way. Only in this world has that been practically exhibited. For the aspirants, occasional lila which are adverse to the eternal lila have been reflected for the instruction of the devotees, aspirants will hope that those lilas will destroy their own evil.
Occasional lilas are: (1) Killing of Putana – Putana is a deceitful Guru, teaching enjoyment and salvation, so crafty sadhus who are fond of these represent Putana-tattva. For showing mercy to His pure devotees, child Krsna kills Putana to safeguard His new born feeling in their hearts.” (Sri Caitanya Siksamrita)
The following essay was printed in the January 1932 edition of The Harmonist.
The first act of New-born Infant Krsna recorded by the Bhagavatam is the slaying of the demoness Putana. She was deputed by King Kamsa to kill all the newborn babies of the realm of Braja where the Divine sage Narada informed him that his would-be slayer had recently been born. Meanwhile Sri Krsna had been born in Kamsa’s prison and had been conveyed by His father Vasudeva to the house of His foster parents Nanda and Yasoda in Braja during the night of His advent. The guards of the prison had failed to detect the movements of Vasudeva who had returned to his prison with the new-born daughter of Yasoda with whom he had exchanged His own Boy without the knowledge of Yasoda herself. Vasudeva had carried Krsna in his arms across the flooded Yamuna lashed into fury by the tempestuous water of that moon-less night. He had waded on foot the deep waters which had been turned into yawning whirlpools by the fury of the tempest. The iron chains, bolts and locks of the barred gates of the prison had opened of their own accord on the approach of Vasudeva carrying Krsna to the home of His foster parents. The daughter of Yasoda was thereupon duly reported to King Kamsa as the new-born-dreaded eighth issue of Devaki. The King rushed into the prison-cell on receipt of the tidings for which he had been waiting through long years of sleepless nights.
He was at first willing to spare the life of the baby as the prophecy was to the effect that he would be killed by a male child, eighth issue of Vasudeva and Devaki but he thought of being relieved of all possible doubts on the point by putting to death the new-born girl. As, however, King Kamsa was on the point of dashing the baby on the block she escaped from the grip of the King and disclosing herself as the Deluding Energy of Godhead as she remained visible for a short time in mid-sky, assured the King of the certainty of the birth of his future slayer but dissuading him from the fruitless attempt of avoiding his fate by the cruel murder of innocent infants. Saying this, Maha-Maya disappeared from the view of the astounded King. Kamsa was subsequently informed by the sage Narada that his future slayer must have been born among the denizens of Braja and that he was mindful of his safety he should lose no time in taking drastic measures for nipping the danger in the bud. This advice was relished by the blood-thirsty coward and he accordingly deputed the demoness Putana to kill by an unsuspected process all the new-born infants of the surrounding country.
The demoness Putana accordingly made her appearance in Braja and presented herself in the home of Yasoda during the absence of Nanda who was then in Mathura to pay the tribute due from him to King Kamsa. The demoness has assumed the form of a most beautiful matron with a most benignant aspect as she approached the couch where Infant Krsna had been put to sleep by Yasoda. Yasoda noticed the unknown female as she entered the house, but did not suspect any foul play. She accordingly watched the new-comer without any anxiety as she made her way to the couch of the Baby, took Him up in her arms and offered her breast to the Infant to give Him to suck. But the nipples of Putana’s breast had been tipped with the deadliest poison.
The infant Krsna was aware of the intention of the demoness and took hold of the breast of the monster with His supple arms. The grip of the Infant was so terribly severe that it was enough to drive the demoness to despair of her life as she was convulsed by the mortal agony of the pressure of Krsna’s little hands. The Infant then applied His lips to the breast of Putana and sucked away her life in an instant. The terrible monster bellowing with pain was compelled to disclose her own huge, loathsome demoniac form as she fell lifeless on the ground covering with her hideous carcass a long distance with Infant Krsna still clinging to her poisoned nipples.
Accordingly the first act of the milkmaids, who with Yasoda rushed to the spot, was to snatch the Infant Krsna from the breast of the terrible demoness. Then they all marveled how the Baby could escape unhurt from the clutches of the demoness. They attributed the safety of the Infant to the mercy of the gods who are especially kind to the helpless. The affrighted milkmaids invoked the help of all the gods and goddesses for their continued protection of the Infant.
Meanwhile, Putana was saved by her service to Krsna for having offered Him the suck of her poisoned breast. The author of the Bhagavatam is careful to mention that the good fortune of the demoness equalled that of Yasoda in as much as her breast had been sucked by Krsna. Putana, therefore, attained to the eternal status of the foster-mothers of the Supreme Lord in the Realm of the Absolute.
The above narrative of the Bhagavatam embodies a most important moral for the seekers of the Absolute. But before offering the interpretations of the texts favoured by the former Acharyas I would like to draw the attention of the reader to certain possible misconceptions regarding the nature of the interpretations about to be offered.
The transcendental meaning of the words cannot be conveyed to the senses of the conditioned soul so long as he does not agree to follow the method of submissive listening to the transcendental sound appearing on the lips of the pure devotee. There is a definite line of succession of the bonafide teachers of the truth. The bonafide teacher should be available sooner or later to the real seeker of the Truth. The bonafide Acarya is not recognizable by the hypocrites and atheists who do not really want to serve Godhead. So long therefore, as the bonafide teacher does not manifest his appearance to the pure cognitive essence of the seeker of the Absolute Truth it is necessary for the candidate for spiritual enlightenment to concentrate on self-examination to be able to avoid harboring any lurking traces of insincerity. The words of the sadhu are also available, by his causeless mercy, for bearing the efforts of such candidates, for finding out their own insincerity.
It is by overlooking or deliberately neglecting to undergo this preliminary training for obtaining access to the transcendental meaning of all words that the literal interpretationists who follow the ordinary lexicographical meaning of the words of the scriptures fail to understand the necessity of never deviating from the interpretations offered by the self-realized souls to whom the transcendental meaning of the words is available. Those empiricists who, while following the lexicographical and syntactical method of the literal interpretationists, do not scruple to read their own meanings into the texts under the impression that the scriptures are the products of the human brain, liable to every form of error and, therefore, fit to be corrected by the equally erring caprices of other hypothetical thinkers on the ground of allegations of error that cannot be proved [and who] are disposed to think that the interpretations offered by the Acharyas are not scrupulously faithful to the texts and [, therefore,] offer allegorical explanations for supporting their own sectarian views.
These possible misunderstandings are stated to invite the attention of the reader to their bearing on the following interpretation of the narrative of Putana based on the exposition of the former Acharyas heard from the lips of the bonafide teacher of the Absolute. The interpretation is not offered as a literal lexicographical explanation nor as an allegory concocted in the light of empiric knowledge of the past history of the race and may accordingly be accepted as such. Sri Krsna manifests His Eternal birth in the pure cognitive essence of the serving soul who is located above all mundane limitations. King Kamsa is the typical aggressive empiricist. He is ever on the look-out for the Appearance of the Truth for the purpose of suppressing Him before He has time to grow up. This is no exaggeration of the real connotation of the consistent empiric position. The materialist has a natural repugnance for the transcendental. He is disposed to think that faith in the incomprehensible is the parent of dogmatism and hypocrisy under the guise of religion. He is also equally under the delusion that there is and can be no really dividing line between the material and the spiritual. He is strengthened in his delusion by the interpretation of the scriptures by persons who are like-minded with himself. This included all the lexicographical interpreters. The lexicographical interpretation is upheld by Kamsa as the real scientific explanation of the Scriptures and one that is perfectly in keeping with his dread of an aversion of the transcendental. These lexicographical interpreters are employed by Kamsa in putting down the first suspected appearance of any genuine faith in the transcendental. King Kamsa knows very well that if the faith in the transcendental is once allowed to grow it is sure to upset all his empiric prospects. There is historical ground for such misgivings.
Accordingly if the empiric domination is to be preserved intact it would be necessary not to lose a moment to put down the transcendental heresy the instant it threatens to make its appearance in right earnest. King Kamsa acting on this transitional fear is never slow to take the scientific precaution of debuting empiric teachers of the scriptures backed by the resources of dictionary and grammar and all empiric subtleties to put down, by the show of spacious arguments based on hypothetical principles, the true interpretation of the eternal religion revealed by the scriptures. Kamsa is strongly persuaded that the faith in the transcendental can be effectively put down by empiricism if prompt and decisive measures are adopted at the very outset. He attributes the failures of atheism in the past to the neglect of the adoption of such measures before the theistic fallacy has time to spread among the fanatical masses.
But Kamsa is found to count without his host. When Krsna is born He is found to be able to upset all sinister designs against those who are apprised by Himself of His Advent. The apparently causeless faith displayed by persons irrespective of age, sex and condition may confound all rabid empiricists who are on principle averse to the Absolute Truth Whose Appearance is utterly incompatible with the domination of empiricism. But no adverse efforts of the empiricists, whose rule seems till then to be perfectly well-established over the minds of the deluded souls of this world, can dissuade any person from exclusively following the Truth when He actually manifests His birth in the pure cognitive essence of His soul.
Putana is the slayer of all infants. The baby, when he or she comes out of the mother’s womb, falls at once into the clutches of the pseudo-teachers of religion. These teachers are successful in forestalling the attempts of the good preceptor whose help is never sought by the atheists of this world at the baptisms of their children. This is ensured by the arrangements of all the established churches of the world. They have been successful only in supplying watchful Putanas for effecting the spiritual destruction of persons from the moment of their birth with the co-operation of their worldly parents. No human contrivance can prevent these Putanas from obtaining possession of the pulpits. This is due to the general prevalence of atheistic disposition in the people of this world. The church that has the best chance of survival in this damned world is that of atheism under the convenient guise of theism. The churches have always proved the staunchest upholders of the grossest forms of worldliness from which even the worst of non-ecclesiastical criminals are bound to recoil.
It is not from any deliberate opposition to the ordained clergy that these observations are made. The original purpose of the established churches of the world may not be always objectionable. But no stable religious arrangement for instructing the masses has yet been successful. The supreme Lord Sri Krsna Chaitanya in pursuance of the teaching of the scriptures enjoins all absence of conventionalism for the teachers of the eternal religion. It does not follow that the mechanical adoption of the unconventional life by any person will make him a fit teacher of religion. Regulation is necessary for controlling the inherent worldliness of conditioned souls. But no mechanical regulation has any value even for such a purpose. The bonafide teacher of the religion is neither any product nor the favourer of any mechanical system. In his hands no system has likewise the chance of degenerating if not a lifeless arrangement. The mere pursuit of fixed doctrines and fixed liturgies cannot hold a person to the true spirit of doctrine or liturgy.
The idea of an organized church in an intelligible form, indeed, marks the close of the living spiritual movement. The great ecclesiastical establishments are the dykes and the dams to retain the current that cannot be held by any such contrivances. They, indeed, indicate a desire on the part of the masses to exploit a spiritual movement for their own purpose. They also unmistakably indicate the end of the absolute and unconventional guidance of the bonafide spiritual teacher. The people of this world understand preventive systems; they can have no idea of the unprevented positive eternal life. Neither can there be any earthly contrivance for the permanent preservation of the life eternal on this mundane plane on the popular scale.
Those are, therefore, greatly mistaken who are disposed to look forward to the amelioration of the worldly state in any worldly sense from the worldly success of any really spiritual movement. It is these worldly expectants who become the patrons of the mischievous race of the pseudo-teachers of religion, the Putanas, whose congenial function is to stifle the theistic disposition at the very moment of its suspected appearance. But the real theistic disposition can never be stifled even by the efforts of those Putanas. The Putanas have power only over the atheists. It is a thankless but salutary task which they perform for the benefit of their willing victims.
But as soon as the theistic disposition proper makes its appearance in the pure cognitive essence of the awakened soul the Putanas are decisively silenced at the very earliest stage of their encounter with new-born Krsna. The would-be slayer is herself slain. This is the reward of the negative services that the Putanas unwittingly render to the cause of theism by strangling all hypocritical demonstrations against their own hypocrisy. But Putana does not at all like to receive her reward in the only form which involves the total destruction of her wrong personality. King Kamsa also does not like to lose the service of the most trusted of his agents. The effective silencing of the whole race of the pseudo-teachers of religion is the very first clear indication of the Appearance of the Absolute on the mundane plane. The bonafide teacher of the Absolute heralds the Advent of Krsna by his uncompromising campaign against the pseudo-teachers of religion.